Aru, Arafura and Timor Seas, Indonesia Snapper – Grouper

Workplan (1January – 31 December 2018)

 

Scope

Three species – Lutjanusmalabaricus (Malabar snapper), L. erythropterus (crimson or scarlet snapper), and Pristipomoidesmultidens (gold band snapper) – are the most economically important fish for export from Indonesia. Total landing of snapper in Indonesia was118,608 tonnes in 2011, with Eastern Timor Sea, Aru Bay, and the Arafura Sea being the major fishing grounds for this species, contributing to more than 30 percent of the total catch, with 46,236 tonnes landed (MMAF 2011). The 2011 data is the most up to date data available from the Indonesian Ministry of Fisheries. Find 3 years of Intan Seafoods catch data for these species on FishSource on Sustainable Fisheries Partnership website.

Three main grouper species – Epinephelus bleekeri (Duskytail grouper), Epinephelus tauvina (Greasy grouper) and Epinepheluspoecilonotus (Dot-dash grouper) are among the catch of bottom longline and handline vessels beside snapper. These three grouper species are also important fish for export. However, surprisingly grouper data is not yet available from government catch statistics in any WPP in Indonesia. Intan Seafood is recording Grouper catch data from several WPPs..Find three years of Intan Seafoods catch data for three years on FishSource.

Information on the National status of the stock for both for snapper and grouper is not available.The only comprehensive stock assessment at the regional scale is the Indonesia and Australia shared stock of red snappers in the Arafura and Timor Seas that was conducted between 1999 and 2003.No capacity for stock assessment using either government data or FIP data has been developed. The most comprehensive information for these Indonesian species is industry catch data complied on FishSource.

There are no set biological reference points, therefore the status of the Indonesian snapper and grouper populations cannot be accurately determined. This situation will continue until such time as data collection, stock assessment, and management capacity are developed within the Indonesian government fisheries framework. As Snapper and Grouper are demersal and territorial in nature this FIP will begin to employ simple stock health indicator for local populations in 2019.

There are no specific management objectives set and no national fishery management plans. As with all other fisheries in Indonesia, the management strategy so far has only been to try to control the fishing efforts by controlling IUU fishing, trying to limit the types of fishing gear used i.e. bottom trawl ban 2016, and limiting fishing vessel size thereby effectively reducing the size of the fleet.

Small vessels are poorly documented and have no formal catch data reporting. Therefore it is unknown if the reduction in fleet and IUU fishing has had any effect on inshore Snapper and Grouper populations.

The improvement need identified in this fishery isthe development of a management plan for snapper-grouper fisheries for both inshore and deep water fisheries.The FIP can contribute to this effort bycontinuing the availability of accurate catch data for stock assessment and uploading catch data to global data bases e.g. FishSource.

This FIP will review International Labor Organization standards to apply these standards under a certification scheme and replace conventional social audits. The purpose of this task is to use existing standards that are recognized internationally in place of conventional social audits. There are only 3 successful social audits in the wild catch sector of the Indonesian seafood industry. The dismal rate of uptake is caused by serious dislocations and greatly increased costs that result from conventional audits. Neither social audits nor Indonesian labor law specifically address the seasonal nature of the capture fisheries sector. The lack of consistent supply caused by seasonality and weather must be addressed in order to create broader support for the certification of fair labor practices and reasonable working conditions in the wild caught seafood industry .

Workplan

This FIP supports and contributes to the improvement of sustainability ofsnapper-grouper in Indonesia, through FIP development in near shore fisheries in various WPPs in Indonesia.The FIP forecasted outcomes for 2018 are to:

  • Continue to accumulate accurate catch data and upload to Fish Source.
  • Apply certified International Labor Organization standards to operations in place of conventional audit o Implement a document tracking system for SIMP audit.
  • Add 2018 workplan to replace 2017 workplan in detailed workplan.
 
TOPIC DELIVERABLES TASK RESPONSIBLE DEADLINE STATUS Evidence
  • Continue reporting catch data
  • Archive catch data in house as well as upload to FishSource  and other international data bases

 

Archive Excelsheet quarterly. The Format continuing 2017_1_SnapperGrouper_

CatchData

Geerry Kosasih

Rona Pasaribu

31 May 2018

31 August 2018

31 October 2018

31 January 2019

Completed

Completed

2017

2018

  • Develop a White Paper supporting the use of ILO standards in the place of social audits. 
  • Review ILO standards, Indonesian Labor Law, and fisheries labor rights according to International Seafares Union. 

 

Publish the White Paper  Rona Pasaribu

Gerald C. Knecht

Brant Connors

October 15, 2018 Completed  White Paper

 

  • Map ILO  standards for seasonal business / maritime industries, applicable sections of Indonesian Labor Law, and International Seafares Union

 

Review ILO labor standards,  Contrast and compare ILO standards for seasonal business/maritime industries with similar sections of Indonesian labor law and applicable International Seafares Union rules. Rona Pasaribu

Gerald C. Knecht

Brant Connors

April 2018

September 2018

In process 50%

completed

  • Create gap analysis of ILO labor standards vs conventional social audit to applied to Indonesia wild caught fisheries seafood producers

 

Review ILO labor standards,  Contrast and compare ILO standards for seasonal business/maritime industries with similar sections of Indonesian labor law and applicable International Seafares Union rules. Rona Pasaribu July 2018

 

October 2018

In progress 50%

Completed

  • Demonstrate application of certified ILO labor standards / International Seafares Union rules as replacement for conventional social audits at Our Oceans Conference in Bali 27 – 28 October

 

Present findings at the Our Oceans Conference  in Bali 27-28 October 2018 Rona Pasaribu

Gerald C. Knecht

Brant Connors

Alexander Knecht

 

October 2018 Preparation
  • Document location of small vessel supply < 30 gt
  • Map of buying locations to WPP and closest landmass

 

Identify tonnage and species from each location quarterly Intan Seafood 31 July 2018

31 October 2018

31 January 2019

On going
  • Traceability
  • Install internal system to comply with SIMP audit standards

 

SIMP documentation Geerry Kosasih April 2018 On going

80% on manual traceability

40% on electronic traceability

  • FIP Meetings
  • Attend annual FIP meeting

 

Review 2018 workplan and budget Sponsor and all participants March 2018

Boston, MA USA

Completed 2018 FIP Meeting